My goal is to define the boundaries more clearly and make sure we use consistent language so we don’t talk past one another so much.
I do not think we are settled on max-set-by-patrons for alpha MVP. I think the simplest possible iterative MVP (and I really want us to determine next-MVP and move forward) is actually the snowdrift project (us) setting the rate and the max (so that’s the 2nd item from my list). Thus, we just switch from kick-out at fixed $10 budget to stating at a project level that we will only run crowdmatching up to $10/patron = $10,000 goal. We could run updated alpha with clearer messaging around that alpha-MVP and wider announcements once ready etc. Then, we continue working (in discussion with projects potentially) on whether the beta-MVP will be the same or add more levers.
I don’t know about “final mechanism”, but yes, we are discussing the longer-term path often. I will separately post about the importance of deciding on and moving forward on alpha before setting later mechanism strictly.